Our Services

Knowledgeable Customer Service

Our trained employees are ready to help you find the perfect toy! We can help you find appropriate toys for all ages and learning styles, with game and toy samples readily available. Come play with us!

Free Gift Wrapping

Our gift wrap is complimentary year round. On your way to the party and short on time? Overwhelmed with Santa's stack? We got you covered. 

Wish Lists

Wish lists make it easy for parents, grandparents, and party-goers. Your child will enjoy choosing their favorites from our hand-picked selection. Win, win!

Our Philosophy

"We believe that it is important to fill our minds with things that are “good and worthy of praise…things that are true and honorable…right and pure…beautiful and respected.” As a child grows the playthings he or she uses should provide positive play experiences that encourage creativity and wholesome learning. It is our goal to offer parents, grandparents, teachers, and care-givers playthings that will help enrich the lives of their children. We do this by hand selecting toys made of quality materials that are fun and encourage creative thinking."

-Don and Kathy Beamen, Owners

Frequently Asked Questions

Can you place orders by phone?

Yes! Our staff is always ready with suggestions for all ages. We can help you pick the perfect toy, gift wrap it, and have it ready for you to pick up. Call us at 812-477-2720 for your next party need!

Do you work with special needs?

Yes! The owner, Kathy, has been educated in special needs and will guide you towards the right products for your child.

Is Toys to Treasure a chain?

No! Toys to Treasure has been locally owned for 30 years by the Beaman family. We started our business on Morgan Avenue, but now call Burkhardt our home. Our kids grew up in the store, just as many of you have grown up shopping here!

What types of toys do you carry?

All of our products are carefully selected with your child in mind. Our toys are well made, educational, and most cannot be found in mass market stores. We carry a wide selection for ages 0-99. Don't let growing up stop you from coming to check out our family games and puzzles!

Are gift cards available?

Yes! Gift cards are available in any denomination.

Do we buy used toys?

No, we only buy new products from toy companies.